Predictive Power: How AI Is Helping Workers' Comp Insurers Stay Ahead of Demographic Shifts

America's shifting workforce demographics, combined with health care policy changes, are fundamentally altering workers' compensation risk profiles and requiring insurers to adopt innovative strategies.

In 2025, employees under 25 and over 55 now comprise nearly 40% of the labor market. This dual trend—an influx of employees newer to physically demanding roles alongside experienced employees extending their careers—creates new challenges in managing workplace injuries and claims. At the same time, evolving health care legislation and economic pressures are reshaping the workers' compensation landscape.

The Changing Workforce Landscape

Newer Employees: Different Work Experience Profiles

Employees new to physically demanding roles may have less familiarity with established safety protocols, potentially leading to different injury patterns that require targeted prevention strategies.

Considerations for Insurers:

• Digital-first safety training tailored to diverse learning preferences
• Predictive analytics to identify opportunities for enhanced safety protocols
• Stronger onboarding programs emphasizing hazard awareness

Experienced Employees: Diverse Health Considerations

Employees with longer careers bring valuable expertise but may have different health considerations that can affect recovery timelines and return-to-work planning.

Considerations for Employees:

• Varied claim durations and medical cost profiles
• Opportunities for workplace adaptations and equipment customization
• Personalized return-to-work strategies for physically demanding roles

Policy Headwinds: Health Care Reform and Workers’ Compensation Fallout

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects 11.8 million Americans could lose health coverage over the next decade due to proposed Medicaid cuts and Affordable Care Act (ACA) enrollment barriers. This could drive more injured employees to seek care through workers’ compensation systems, leading to increased claim volumes, cost shifting, more causation disputes and potential treatment delays.

Three Emerging Trends Insurers Must Watch

1. Inflation Pressures

Health care costs continue their upward trajectory in 2025, with employer-sponsored coverage projected to jump 9% and exceed $16,000 per employee. With health care spending forecast to rise 5.4% annually through 2028, businesses face persistent medical inflation challenges, potentially driving workers' compensation premiums higher.

2. Mental Health and PTSD Claims

Mental health challenges affect 20% of American adults annually, with only one-third seeking help. During the 2025 legislative sessions, industry analysts are tracking more than 86 bills addressing mental health in workers' compensation.

Research published in JAMA (February 2025) demonstrates that mental health outcomes deteriorate more significantly following workplace injuries, with PTSD, anxiety and depression representing the majority of workers' compensation mental health claims.

3. Marijuana Legalization

With 74% of Americans living in states where marijuana is legal in some form, insurers face a patchwork of conflicting regulations, complicated drug testing, claim investigations and return-to-work decisions. This challenge is particularly relevant when managing claims from employees in states with recreational use laws alongside those who may be using marijuana medicinally for various health conditions.

Strategic Imperatives for Insurers

Claims Management Innovation

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and predictive analytics can flag high-risk claims early, streamline processing and personalize recovery. Specific actions include:

• Implementing experience-based risk assessment in claims triage
• Developing specialized protocols for different injury types and recovery patterns
• Creating specialized teams for complex claims involving multiple health factors

Telemedicine and Digital Health

Telehealth offers faster, more accessible care that appeals to tech-savvy workers while benefiting those with mobility or transportation challenges through reduced travel and better condition management.

Insurers should:

• Integrate telehealth options into first-report-of-injury protocols
• Develop virtual physical therapy programs for appropriate cases
• Utilize remote monitoring for ongoing condition management

Tailored Risk Mitigation

Successful risk management strategies must address the diverse needs of today's workforce through customized approaches that recognize individual differences rather than relying on one-size-fits-all solutions:

• Cross-generational mentorship programs that facilitate knowledge sharing across experience levels
• Diverse training approaches to accommodate different learning preferences
• Personalized ergonomic assessments to accommodate diverse physical needs across the workforce
• Comprehensive drug policies that address diverse populations
   

Looking Ahead to the New Normal

The convergence of demographic shifts and health care policy changes is not a passing phase, it's the new normal. Insurers who proactively adapt will be best positioned to manage risk, control costs, and deliver value by embracing technology, tailoring safety strategies and preparing for systemic health care gaps. As these trends accelerate, successful insurers will be those who view these challenges as opportunities to innovate and differentiate in an increasingly complex market.

The organizations that thrive will develop integrated approaches addressing the full spectrum of workforce experience levels while preparing for health care coverage gaps that may drive more injured employees into the workers' compensation system. By acting now to implement inclusive safety protocols, technology-enabled claims management and comprehensive mental health support, insurers can transform these challenges into competitive advantages.

To learn more about what the Enlyte government affairs team is working on and stay up to date on this and other regulatory issues, sign up to receive our monthly Compliance Connection Newsletter.